Calgary, AB

Serving twenty neighbourhoods without building twenty thin pages.

Every local business is told to make a page for each area it covers. Done the usual way it produces twenty near-identical pages, and a site that is worse than it was before. There is a version that works.

By · Last reviewed

Check my site→
On this page5 sections

Why do neighbourhood pages usually fail?

Because they are one page rewritten with the place name swapped, and that is a pattern search engines have been filtering for a very long time.

The standard version takes a services page and produces one copy per area, changing a noun. "Plumber in Tuscany", "Plumber in Mahogany", "Plumber in Bridgeland" — same paragraphs, same headings, same photos. There is nothing on any of them that could only have been written about that place.

Two things go wrong. The pages themselves rarely rank, because there is no reason to prefer any of them. And they drag: a site whose page count is mostly thin duplicates is a weaker site overall, so the pages that were working have to carry them.

The tell is simple and worth applying to your own drafts. If you could swap the place name and the page would still be accurate, it should not be a separate page.

When does a location page genuinely deserve to exist?

When you can write something true about working in that specific place that is not true of the others — different housing stock, a different regulation, a different job entirely.

That bar is real and it is passable more often than people expect, but not twenty times. A plumber can write a genuinely specific page about the inner-city communities where poly-B plumbing shows up in a particular era of housing, because that is a different job with different costs. The same plumber cannot write nineteen more like it.

A physical location always deserves a page. A second shop, a second clinic, a second yard — those are real places with their own address, hours and staff, and each one should have its own page and its own Business Profile.

Everything else is one page.

Check my site

The same checks this page describes, run against your own site. About 30 seconds.

Check my site→

What should you build instead?

One strong service-areas page that names everywhere you go, plus service pages that are genuinely deep. The service page is what ranks; the areas page answers "do you come here?"

Splitting your effort across twenty thin pages is the alternative to putting it into one page that is actually worth reading. The second wins on every measure that matters.

One service-areas page
Names every community and town you cover, with anything genuinely different about each — travel charges, minimum call-out, days you are in that part of the city. Real operational detail, not a list of links.
A real page per service
This is where the ranking actually comes from. "Emergency drain clearing" is a search; "plumber in Tuscany" is mostly a search Google answers with the map pack anyway.
Proof from around the city
Jobs, photos and specifics that happen to be in different communities, on the relevant service page. This is how a page earns local relevance honestly.
The Business Profile service areas
Set them properly in your profile. For a service-area business this does more for local visibility than any page on your site.

How should a service-area business set up its Google profile?

Hide the address, set the service areas to the places you actually go, and do not invent an address to appear closer to a customer.

If customers do not come to your premises, Google's guidelines say to hide the address and declare service areas instead. Businesses run from home often resist this because the address feels like proof of legitimacy; showing it is a violation and a common cause of a suspended listing.

Set the service areas honestly. A radius that covers places you would not actually drive to is not a ranking strategy — proximity to the searcher is a heavy factor in the map pack and declaring a wide area does not overcome it. It just makes the profile less accurate.

As a reference point, this business declares five: Calgary, Airdrie, Chestermere, Cochrane and Okotoks. That is the honest extent of it, and both the site and the profile say the same five.

Can you rank in a suburb you have no address in?

In the ordinary blue-link results, yes. In the map pack, distance from the searcher is a heavy factor and there is no page you can write that removes it.

This is the honest limit and it is the thing the twenty-page strategy is usually sold as a solution to. Two businesses with equal profiles, one four kilometres from the searcher and one eighteen, will not place the same in the map pack, and no amount of content fixes that.

What is genuinely winnable is the organic results underneath the map, where distance matters far less. That is another argument for depth: a strong page about the actual job can rank across the whole city, while a thin page about a neighbourhood competes for a slot that proximity has already decided.

The trades feel this most sharply, because their whole market is other people's houses. Plumbers and HVAC companies both do better with one deep page about a job the city genuinely has — an era of piping, a season of failures — than with twenty pages about suburbs.

If you want the mechanics of that split, how the map pack is decided sets out which of the three factors you can move.

Common questions

My competitor has forty location pages and outranks me.
Check what they rank for rather than assuming it is the pages. Very often the ranking comes from their profile, their reviews and their proximity, and the location pages get no traffic at all. Copying the visible half of someone else's site is how bad patterns spread.
How many areas can I list on my Google profile?
Google allows up to twenty service areas, and using all twenty is rarely the right call. List the places you genuinely serve; a profile claiming areas you would decline work in is inaccurate, and accuracy is what the listing is for.
I already built twenty thin pages. Should I delete them?
Usually merge rather than delete. Take the genuinely useful content into one strong service-areas page and redirect the thin ones to it, so any links they have earned are kept. Deleting outright throws that away.
Does the city name in my page titles help?
Naming the city on your main service pages is worth doing — it is one of the clearest signals of what a page is for. Repeating twenty different community names across twenty near-identical titles is the version that does not work.

Related

Find out if something's broken before you spend anything.

The free check takes about 30 seconds and asks for nothing — not even your email. From $499 a month if you want it fixed.

Check my site→