Calgary, AB

How to get more Google reviews, without getting your listing pulled.

Reviews are the part of local search a business owner can genuinely control, and the part most often gone about in a way that risks the listing. This is the line between asking and buying.

By · Last reviewed

Check my site→
On this page6 sections

Do reviews actually affect where you rank?

They contribute, but not as directly as most owners assume. Google names prominence as one of three factors alongside relevance and proximity, and reviews are one input into prominence.

The version of this that gets repeated — more reviews equals higher ranking — is too simple to act on. Proximity to the searcher is a heavy factor in the map pack and you cannot change your address. Relevance comes largely from your categories and your website. Reviews sit inside the third factor, prominence, along with everything else that suggests a business is well known.

What that means practically: a business with forty honest reviews and the wrong primary category will usually lose to one with twelve reviews and the right one. Fix the category first. Reviews compound quietly underneath it, and they do far more work on the conversion side — the person choosing between three map results is reading them.

If you have not looked at how the map pack is actually decided, start there. It explains which of the three factors you can move and which you cannot.

What is the rule about asking for reviews?

You may ask. You may not offer anything in return, filter who you ask, or ask in bulk from a single device or network.

Google's policy prohibits review gating — asking customers privately how it went and only routing the happy ones to Google — and prohibits incentives of any kind, including discounts, entries into a draw, and free product. It does not prohibit simply asking, which is the part owners are most nervous about and the part that is fine.

The practical failure is rarely a deliberate scheme. It is a tablet by the till where twenty reviews are left from the same IP address in a week, or a well-meaning staff member offering a free coffee. Both look exactly like the thing the policy exists to stop.

Ask everyone, not just the pleased ones. Ask in the customer's own time on their own phone. That is the whole compliant method.

When is the right moment to ask?

At the point the job is visibly finished and the customer is satisfied — not at invoice time, and not by email three weeks later.

For a trade, that is standing in the room looking at the finished work. For a clinic or a salon, it is at the desk on the way out. For anything with a follow-up appointment, it is the moment the outcome is confirmed rather than the moment the service was delivered.

The single highest-yield change most businesses can make is asking out loud instead of hoping. A link in an email footer converts poorly; a person saying "if that worked out for you, a Google review genuinely helps us" converts well, and takes no budget.

Use the short link
Your Business Profile provides a direct review link. Sending someone to search for you first loses most of them, and risks them reviewing the wrong listing.
One ask, not a campaign
A single request at the right moment. Repeated chasing reads as pressure and is what makes people mention it in the review.
Ask by name where you can
Reviews that mention the specific service or the person who did the work are more useful to the next reader, and to Google's understanding of what you do.
Never route by sentiment
Any process that asks how it went before deciding whether to request a review is gating, and it is against policy regardless of intent.

Check my site

The same checks this page describes, run against your own site. About 30 seconds.

Check my site→

What should you do about a bad review?

Reply once, briefly, in public, without arguing. The reply is written for everyone who reads it afterwards, not for the person who left it.

A defensive reply does more damage than the review. So does a reply that reveals details about the customer, which in a clinical or legal setting can also be a professional-conduct problem before it is a marketing one.

The pattern that works: acknowledge the specific thing, state briefly what you do differently or what you have changed, and offer to take it offline with a real contact point. Three sentences. The audience is the next prospective customer scrolling past it.

A steady stream of honest reviews is also the best insurance against a single bad one, because it moves down the page and stops being the first thing anybody reads.

Can you get a review removed?

Only if it violates Google's policies — spam, conflict of interest, off-topic, personal information. "It is unfair" is not grounds, and most flagged reviews stay up.

The realistic cases are a review left on the wrong business, a competitor review, a review containing personal or identifying information, or content that is abusive rather than an account of a service. Those are worth flagging through your Business Profile, and worth being patient about — the process is slow and there is no appeal you can escalate by phone.

A negative but genuine account of a bad experience will not be removed, and pursuing it is time better spent on the reply and on the next twenty customers.

How many reviews do you actually need?

Enough to not look abandoned, and recent enough to look open. There is no threshold that flips a switch.

Look at the businesses currently holding the three map slots for the search you care about, and read their counts. That is the real benchmark for your category and your city, and it is usually lower than owners fear.

Two exceptions worth knowing about. A regulated profession has standards of its own on soliciting testimonials — see what that changes for a dental practice — and a restaurant is the opposite case, where reviews are read more closely than any page you will ever write.

Recency matters more than volume past a point. A business with sixty reviews where the newest is from two years ago reads worse to a human than one with fifteen where the newest is from last month. Whatever process you adopt, the goal is a slow steady trickle rather than a burst.

Common questions

Can I offer a discount for a review?
No. Any incentive — a discount, a draw entry, a free item — breaks Google's policy whether or not you ask for a positive review specifically. Reviews obtained that way can be removed, and repeated cases put the listing itself at risk.
Is it against the rules to ask only happy customers?
Yes. That is review gating and Google prohibits it explicitly. Any process that checks sentiment before deciding who gets asked falls under it, including the several third-party tools that sell exactly that as a feature.
Should I reply to positive reviews too?
It is worth doing and it takes seconds, but keep it short and varied. A page of identical thank-yous reads as automated. There is no confirmed ranking benefit to replying; the benefit is that a reader sees a business that pays attention.
A competitor clearly has fake reviews. What can I do?
Flag them through the profile and then let it go. Reporting is the only legitimate route, it is slow, and it frequently results in no action. Building your own honest count is a better use of the same hour.

Related

Find out if something's broken before you spend anything.

The free check takes about 30 seconds and asks for nothing — not even your email. From $499 a month if you want it fixed.

Check my site→